WordPress

ShortPixel vs Imagify: Which Image Optimization Plugin Reduces File Size More?

WordPress November 5, 2026 16 min read
ShortPixel vs Imagify: Which Image Optimization Plugin Reduces File Size More?

Images are often the heaviest part of a WordPress page, and the easiest part to fix.

A photo straight from a camera or a phone can weigh several megabytes. Put ten of them in a post, and your visitors wait. An image optimization plugin shrinks these files, often by more than half, with little change that the eye can see.

ShortPixel and Imagify are two of the best-known plugins for this job. Both compress images, both can convert them to modern formats, and both run on a credit or quota system. The question that most people ask is simple: which one reduces file size more?

Advertisement

The honest answer is that the result depends on your images and your settings, and the vendors’ own comparisons favor themselves. In this guide, we’ll compare the two plugins fairly, show where the real differences are, and give you a simple way to test both on your own site.

The Short Answer

Both plugins can cut image size a great deal. In the comparison published by ShortPixel, its own plugin reduced file sizes the most, but that is the vendor’s own test, so treat it as a claim.

In general:

  • ShortPixel is a flexible choice with several compression levels, a generous free monthly allowance, and a wide set of features.
  • Imagify is a simple, clean plugin from the makers of WP Rocket, with three clear compression levels, and a quota based on data size.

The best choice depends on how many images you have, how often you upload new ones, and how much control you want. Test both on twenty of your own images, and compare the results.

Why Image Optimization Matters

Large images hurt your site in three ways.

  • They slow down loading, which raises your Largest Contentful Paint time.
  • They use more bandwidth, which costs visitors on mobile data.
  • They fill your server’s disk and your backups.

A good image workflow has four parts: resize images to the size you need, compress them, serve modern formats such as WebP or AVIF, and load them lazily. Our guide on why your WordPress website is so slow explains how images fit into the wider speed picture.

How These Plugins Work

Both ShortPixel and Imagify send your images to an external service, which compresses them and sends them back. Your server does little of the heavy work, which is good for small hosting plans.

ShortPixel

You can find ShortPixel on the ShortPixel Image Optimizer page on WordPress.org. It compresses new uploads automatically, and it can process your existing media library in bulk. It offers several compression levels, backups of your originals, and conversion to modern formats.

Imagify

Imagify is listed on the Imagify page on WordPress.org. It is made by WP Media, the team behind WP Rocket. It also compresses new uploads and the existing library, offers a few clear compression levels, keeps backups of originals, and converts to modern formats.

ShortPixel vs Imagify at a Glance

FeatureShortPixelImagify
Free planMonthly free creditsSmall monthly allowance of data
Quota typeCredits per imageData size in megabytes or gigabytes
Compression levelsLossless, lossy, and glossyNormal, aggressive, and ultra
Modern formatsWebP and AVIF, check current optionsWebP and AVIF, check current options
Bulk optimizationYesYes
Automatic optimization on uploadYesYes
Backup of originalsYesYes
Resize large imagesYesYes
CDN optionYes, through its own serviceNot a main feature
PDF and other file typesYesLimited
Works with WP RocketYesYes, and built by the same team
Pricing styleMonthly or one-time plans by image countMonthly or one-time plans by data size

Features and plan details change often. Check each plugin’s current page. The summary above reflects the vendors’ descriptions, and each vendor writes in its own favor.

Compression Levels Explained

Image compression comes in two main kinds.

  • Lossless compression removes extra data without changing a single pixel. The file gets a little smaller, and the quality stays exactly the same.
  • Lossy compression removes some detail that the eye rarely notices. The file gets much smaller, and the quality drops by a small amount, depending on the level.

ShortPixel levels

  • Lossless: the safest, and the smallest saving.
  • Lossy: a strong saving, with a small quality loss. This is the usual choice for most sites.
  • Glossy: between the two. It aims for a better look, which suits photography sites.

Imagify levels

  • Normal: a light, nearly lossless level.
  • Aggressive: a stronger level, which is the usual choice for most sites.
  • Ultra: the smallest files, with the most visible quality loss.

The names differ, but the idea is the same. For a blog, a lossy or aggressive level is usually the right balance. For a portfolio of photographs, use a gentler level, and check the results by eye.

Which One Reduces File Size More?

Here is the fair answer.

  • On many test sets, both plugins produce similar results at similar levels, and the difference is a few percentage points.
  • The vendors’ own tests usually favor their own plugin. ShortPixel’s comparison says that ShortPixel generally reduced file sizes the most in its test.
  • The result changes with the type of image. A photo with a lot of detail compresses differently from a flat graphic or a screenshot.
  • The result changes with the level that you choose, and with whether you also convert to WebP or AVIF.

The only test that matters is a test on your own images.

How to Run Your Own Test

You can compare both plugins on a staging site in about an hour.

  1. Take a backup, and use a staging copy of your site.
  2. Pick twenty images that represent your site: photos, graphics, screenshots, and logos.
  3. Install the first plugin, and set it to the level you would use in real life.
  4. Optimize the twenty images, and note the total size before and after.
  5. Look at the images at full size and on a phone. Look for banding, blurred edges, and odd colors.
  6. Restore the originals, if the plugin allows, or use fresh copies.
  7. Deactivate and remove the first plugin, and install the second.
  8. Repeat with the same images and a matching level.
  9. Compare total size, quality, and speed of processing.
  10. Check how many credits or how much quota each test used.

Record the numbers in a small table. That gives you a result based on your own content.

Test itemShortPixel resultImagify result
Total size before|
Total size after|
Saving in percent|
Visible quality loss|
Time taken|
Credits or quota used|

Free Plans Compared

Both plugins offer a free allowance, but they count differently.

  • ShortPixel counts credits, and one credit is usually one image or one size of an image. A free monthly allowance covers a small site with few new images.
  • Imagify counts data, and the free allowance is a small amount of data each month. The vendor’s comparison notes a limit on the size of each file in the free version.

Why does this matter? WordPress creates several sizes of each uploaded image, such as thumbnail, medium, and large. A plugin that counts each size as a credit uses the allowance faster than you expect. Check how each plugin counts, and which sizes you can leave out.

Pricing Models

PointShortPixelImagify
Monthly plansBy number of imagesBy amount of data
One-time plansAvailable, by number of imagesAvailable, by data size
Free planYesYes
Good forSites with many small imagesSites with fewer, larger files

Prices change, so check the current pricing pages. When you compare cost, estimate how many images you add each month and how large they are. A site that uploads a few large photographs may do better with a data-based plan, and a site with many small images may do better with a count-based plan.

Modern Image Formats

WebP and AVIF files are much smaller than JPEG and PNG at the same quality.

  • Both plugins can convert images to WebP, and most advertise AVIF support as well. Check the current options.
  • The plugin can serve the new format to browsers that support it, and fall back to the original for others.
  • Serving can happen through rewrite rules, through a picture tag, or through a CDN.

After you turn on modern formats, test your pages in more than one browser, and check that images still show everywhere, including in emails, social sharing, and any plugin that reads image files.

Working With a Caching Plugin and CDN

Image optimization works best with the rest of your speed setup.

  • A caching plugin serves fast pages, and an image plugin makes the images on them smaller. They do different jobs, and they do not conflict.
  • Imagify and WP Rocket come from the same company, and they work together smoothly. ShortPixel also works well with WP Rocket and other caching plugins.
  • If you use a CDN, check that the optimized images are served from it, and clear the CDN cache after you optimize your library.

Our comparison of LiteSpeed Cache vs WP Rocket helps you choose a caching setup, and some caching plugins also include image tools, so check for overlap before you add another plugin.

How to Set Up an Image Optimization Plugin Safely

  1. Take a full backup of your files and database. Our review of UpdraftPlus shows how to set up backups.
  2. Install the plugin and connect your account, if it asks for one.
  3. Choose a compression level, starting with a middle level.
  4. Turn on backup of originals.
  5. Set a maximum image size, such as the largest width that your theme shows.
  6. Turn on automatic optimization for new uploads.
  7. Run the bulk optimizer on a small batch first, and check the images.
  8. Run the bulk optimizer on the full library, at a quiet time.
  9. Turn on modern format delivery, and test.
  10. Measure your speed before and after.

Bulk optimization can use server resources and take hours for a large library. Run it overnight, and keep an eye on your credits.

Common Mistakes

  • Uploading huge images, and relying on the plugin to fix them. Resize first.
  • Using the strongest level on every image, including photographs where quality matters.
  • Deleting originals before you check the results.
  • Running two image optimization plugins at the same time.
  • Forgetting that each image size uses credits.
  • Not testing modern formats on all browsers.
  • Optimizing the library, and then not checking the speed result.
  • Skipping alt text, which matters for accessibility and search.

Which Should You Choose?

Your situationBetter choiceWhy
Small blog, a few images each monthEither, on the free planCompare the free allowances
Many small imagesShortPixelCount-based credits suit small files
Few, large photosImagifyData-based quota may suit large files
You want the most controlShortPixelMore levels and options
You use WP RocketImagify, or ShortPixelBoth work, and Imagify is from the same team
Photography portfolioEither, with a gentle levelCheck quality by eye
You want a CDN for imagesShortPixelA CDN option is part of the service

Resize First, Then Compress

The biggest saving often comes before any plugin runs. A photo that is 6000 pixels wide, shown in a column that is 800 pixels wide, wastes most of its data.

  • Find the widest space that your theme shows an image in. For many blogs, 1200 to 1600 pixels is enough.
  • Resize photos to that width on your computer, or set the plugin to resize large uploads.
  • Use JPEG for photographs, PNG for graphics with sharp edges or transparency, and let the plugin convert to modern formats.
  • Do not upload a PNG screenshot where a JPEG or WebP would do.
  • Name files with clear words, and add alt text for each image.

A resized image, compressed at a middle level, is often 80 to 95 percent smaller than the original. That saving comes from both steps together.

What the Plugins Do With WordPress Image Sizes

When you upload one image, WordPress creates several copies at different sizes, for example thumbnail, medium, medium large, and large. Your theme and plugins may add more.

This has three effects on image optimization.

  • Each size may count against your quota, so one upload can use several credits.
  • Sizes that your theme never shows still take up disk space.
  • Bulk optimization of an old library can use a lot of quota at once.

To save credits, check which sizes your theme uses, and remove the others. Many optimization plugins let you exclude sizes. A cleaner list of sizes makes every plan last longer, and keeps your uploads folder smaller.

Advertisement

Lazy Loading and Image Dimensions

Compression is one part. Loading is the other.

  • Lazy loading delays images that are below the first screen, so that the page appears sooner. Most themes and WordPress itself support it.
  • Do not lazy load the main image at the top of the page. It should load first, because it often sets your Largest Contentful Paint time.
  • Always set width and height on images, so that the page does not jump while loading.
  • Use responsive image sizes, which WordPress adds by default, so that phones receive smaller files.

If your optimization plugin or your caching plugin has a lazy loading option, turn on only one, so that two tools do not work against each other.

Backups, Originals, and Restoring

Both plugins can keep your original files, so that you can undo the compression.

  • Keep this option on, at least until you are happy with the results.
  • Check where the backups are stored, and how much space they take on your server.
  • Know how to restore a single image or the whole library.
  • If your site is hosted on a plan with limited disk space, you may need to remove old backups after some time.

A site-wide backup is still needed. A full backup before a bulk run protects you if something goes wrong with files or the database. Take one first, and keep it until you have checked the results.

Privacy and Data Handling

Because these plugins send your images to an outside service, you should know how that works.

  • Check each vendor’s privacy policy to see how images are processed and how long they are kept.
  • If your images contain personal data, such as photos of people, think about whether processing on an outside server is right for you.
  • Some plugins offer an option to remove metadata from images, such as camera details and location tags. Removing location data is a good habit for photos that you publish.
  • If your site serves visitors in places with strict privacy rules, check what you must say in your privacy policy about outside processors.

Troubleshooting Image Optimization Problems

ProblemLikely causeWhat to try
Images look blurryLevel too strongUse a gentler level, and restore originals
Bulk run stops partwayServer time limit, or low creditsRun smaller batches, check credits, and ask your host about limits
Credits run out fastMany image sizes, or a large libraryExclude unused sizes, and upgrade if needed
WebP images do not showServer or cache issueClear caches, and check the delivery method
Images missing after a CDN setupWrong CDN settingsCheck addresses, and clear the CDN cache
Site gets slower after optimizationHeavy bulk process, or a conflictRun bulk jobs off-peak, and test other plugins
Original files are goneBackup option was offRestore from a site backup

If you suspect that another plugin is clashing, our guide on how to find which plugin is breaking your site shows a safe way to test, and a staging copy is the best place to try.

A Sample Optimization Plan for a Small Blog

Here is a simple plan for a blog with a few hundred images and a few new images each month.

  1. Take a backup, and test on staging.
  2. Install one optimization plugin, and keep the free plan.
  3. Set a middle compression level, such as lossy or aggressive.
  4. Turn on resize for large uploads, with a maximum width that fits your theme.
  5. Turn on automatic optimization for new uploads.
  6. Turn on WebP delivery, and test your pages.
  7. Run the bulk optimizer on the existing library in small batches, as your credits allow.
  8. Measure Largest Contentful Paint and total page size before and after.
  9. Check one page of each type on a phone.
  10. Review credit use after a month, and decide whether to upgrade.

If you add more images than the free plan covers, compare the paid plans on the cost of the images you will really add, not on the biggest tier.

A Sample Plan for a Photography or Shop Site

Sites that depend on image quality need a gentler approach.

  • Use lossless or a gentle level for hero images and product photos, and a stronger level for thumbnails and blog images.
  • Keep originals, and check each setting by eye on a good screen.
  • Use modern formats, and test colors, since some conversions can shift them slightly.
  • Plan for a larger quota, since product galleries use many images.
  • Use a CDN so that images load quickly from a server near the visitor.
  • Test the cart and product pages after each change.

Our Verdict

ShortPixel and Imagify are both reliable. If you want the most control, a wide set of options, and a count-based plan that suits many small images, ShortPixel is a good choice. If you want a simple three-level setup from a team that also makes WP Rocket, and a data-based plan, Imagify is a good choice.

On file size alone, there is no universal winner. The vendors’ own tests favor themselves, and real results vary with your images. A short test on your own sample, with the same settings, tells you more than any review.

Whichever you pick, resize before you upload, use a middle compression level, keep your originals, serve modern formats, and measure the result. That routine gives you most of the possible saving.

Speed of Processing and Server Load

Because both plugins compress images on an outside service, your own server does little work. Still, a bulk run sends many files, and it can take hours on a large library.

  • Run bulk jobs at quiet hours, and in small batches on a small hosting plan.
  • Expect new uploads to be processed within seconds or a few minutes, depending on the plugin’s queue.
  • If the process stops, check your credits, your host’s time limits, and whether a security rule blocks the outside connection.
  • After a large run, clear your caches, and check a few pages to confirm that the new files load.

A short test of how long each plugin takes to process the same twenty images is a useful part of your own comparison, since a slow queue can be annoying when you publish often.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which reduces file size more, ShortPixel or Imagify?

It depends on your images and the level you choose. ShortPixel’s own test says it saved more, but vendor tests favor their authors. Test both on your own images.

Is there a free plan for both?

Yes. Both have a free monthly allowance, counted in different ways.

Will image compression ruin my photos?

Lossless compression does not change the image. Lossy compression changes a little, and a middle level is rarely visible. Check a sample before you run a bulk job.

Should I convert images to WebP or AVIF?

Yes, in most cases, because the files are smaller. Test your site in different browsers after you turn it on.

Can I use both plugins together?

No. Use one image optimizer, so that images are not processed twice.

Does image optimization improve SEO?

It helps by making pages faster, which supports a better experience. It does not replace good content.

Can I get my original images back?

Yes, if you keep the backup option on. Both plugins can restore originals from their backups.

How many credits will I use?

Each image and each size can count. Check how the plugin counts, and exclude sizes that your theme does not use.

Can someone set up my image optimization for me?

Yes. If you want an experienced person to configure and test it, you can get WordPress management help through this Fiverr gig.

Final Thoughts

ShortPixel and Imagify are both capable image optimizers. Both can shrink your images a lot, both can convert to modern formats, and both let you restore originals. The difference in saved file size is often small, and it depends on your images, your level, and your settings.

Test both on a sample of your own images, compare the size and the look, and check how each one counts your quota. Then choose the plugin that fits your site and your budget, and keep resizing images before you upload them. A good image habit does more for speed than any single plugin.

Advertisement
Mindful reading

Better ideas, delivered thoughtfully.

Receive useful articles, thoughtful perspectives and practical knowledge from Mindful Tomorrow without unnecessary noise.

Scroll to Top