WordPress

Wordfence vs Solid Security: Which WordPress Security Plugin Should You Use?

WordPress November 4, 2026 17 min read
Wordfence vs Solid Security: Which WordPress Security Plugin Should You Use?

Your WordPress site is attacked far more often than you think, and most of the attacks are automatic.

Bots test your login page, look for old plugins, and try known weaknesses all day long. A security plugin cannot make a site perfect, but it can block many of these attempts, warn you when something changes, and help you clean up if something goes wrong.

Wordfence and Solid Security are two of the best-known names in this field. Wordfence is famous for its firewall and malware scanner. Solid Security, which used to be called iThemes Security, is known for its hardening tools and simple login protection. Both have free versions, and both have paid plans.

Advertisement

In this guide, we’ll compare Wordfence and Solid Security. We’ll look at how each one works, what the free versions give you, what the paid plans add, and how they affect your site’s speed. Then we’ll help you pick one, and show how to set it up without locking yourself out.

The Short Answer

Choose Wordfence if you want a strong firewall and a detailed malware scanner, and you do not mind a plugin that does a lot of work on your server.

Choose Solid Security if you want clear hardening steps, simple login protection, and a lighter feel, and you like a plugin that guides you through a checklist.

Both are good. Do not run them together. Pick one, set it up with care, and keep the rest of your site updated, because a security plugin cannot protect a site that runs old, weak code.

What Does a Security Plugin Do?

A security plugin works on several layers.

  • Firewall: blocks bad requests before they reach your site’s code.
  • Malware scanner: looks for changed or suspicious files and known bad code.
  • Login protection: limits login attempts and adds a second step, such as an app code.
  • Hardening: closes common weak points, such as file editing from the dashboard or an open user list.
  • Monitoring: tells you when files change, when a user logs in, or when a plugin has a known problem.
  • Alerts and logs: send you a message when something needs attention.

What it cannot do is replace good habits: strong passwords, updates, backups, and careful choice of plugins. Our review of UpdraftPlus and its free backup plan covers the backup side, which is your safety net if a security plugin does not stop an attack.

How Each Plugin Works

Wordfence

Wordfence installs a firewall that runs on your own server, inside WordPress, and a scanner that checks your files against a list of known threats. It also has login security, with rate limiting and two-factor authentication, and a dashboard with live traffic and blocked attempts. You can read more on the Wordfence page on WordPress.org.

Because the firewall runs on your server, it uses your server’s resources. On a small plan, a heavy scan can cause a slowdown if it is not set with care.

Solid Security

Solid Security, from SolidWP, focuses on hardening and login protection. It gives you a list of recommended steps, and applies many of them with a few clicks. It includes brute force protection, two-factor login, strong password rules, file change detection, and a dashboard that shows your security status. The plugin is listed on the Solid Security page on WordPress.org.

The plugin’s name has changed over time, from Better WP Security to iThemes Security to Solid Security, and the plugin directory still uses the older address.

Wordfence vs Solid Security at a Glance

FeatureWordfenceSolid Security
Free versionYesYes
FirewallEndpoint firewall inside WordPressBasic protections in free, more in Pro
Malware scannerDetailed file and code scanScans for file changes and known weak points
Login protectionRate limiting, two-factor, login captchaBrute force protection, two-factor, and more in Pro
Hardening toolsSomeMany, with a guided checklist
AlertsYesYes
Live traffic viewYesLimited
Premium extrasReal-time firewall rules and signatures, country blocking, supportExtra login options, user tools, and support
Server loadHigher during scansUsually lighter
Ease of useMany screens and optionsA simple dashboard and checklist

Features and plan limits change often, so check each vendor’s current feature list. The vendors also publish their own comparison pages, such as the Wordfence comparison page, which you should read with the knowledge that each is written by one side.

Firewall

Wordfence

The firewall is Wordfence’s main feature. It checks requests as they reach WordPress, and blocks those that match attack patterns. It has a learning mode that helps it adapt to your site. In the free version, new firewall rules arrive after a delay compared with the premium version, which gets them in real time. Check the current delay on the vendor’s page.

Solid Security

Solid Security focuses less on a full firewall and more on blocking bad behavior at login and hardening your setup. It can ban repeat offenders and block known bad hosts. If you want a strong web application firewall, you may pair it with a firewall service at the network level.

Which is better?

For a firewall inside WordPress, Wordfence is stronger. For simple hardening and brute force protection, Solid Security is enough for many small sites.

Malware Scanning

Scan featureWordfenceSolid Security
Compare core files with official copiesYesLimited
Check plugin and theme filesYes, for known issuesThrough file change detection
Look for known malware patternsYesLimited in free
Check for known vulnerable pluginsYesYes, with a site check
Scan for bad URLs and contentYesNot in the same way
Repair changed core filesYesLimited

Wordfence has the deeper scanner, and it is a good tool when you suspect a hack. Solid Security’s file change detection is useful to alert you when something changes, but it is not a full malware scanner.

A scanner can also report false alarms, such as a changed file that you edited yourself. Read each finding before you delete anything.

Login Protection

Most attacks on small sites go after the login page.

  • Both plugins limit failed login attempts, and lock out repeat offenders.
  • Both offer two-factor authentication, which asks for a code from an app or by email after the password.
  • Solid Security adds options such as password rules and a hidden login address in its settings, and extra tools in Pro.
  • Wordfence adds login captcha options and a way to block weak passwords.

Two-factor login is the most useful step for any site with several users. Turn it on for administrators first.

Hardening and Site Checks

Hardening means closing weak points in a default install.

  • Turn off the file editor in the dashboard, so that an attacker cannot change code from a stolen login.
  • Limit the visible user list, so that bots cannot read usernames.
  • Hide the version of WordPress from public pages.
  • Block access to sensitive files.
  • Use strong passwords and force password changes when needed.
  • Keep plugins and themes updated.

Solid Security is stronger on this side. It shows a checklist and helps you apply each step. Wordfence has some hardening tools, but it puts its main focus on the firewall and the scanner.

Performance and Server Load

A security plugin always costs some resources, and that cost matters on small hosting plans.

AreaWordfenceSolid Security
Page load impactSmall, since the firewall runs earlySmall
Scan loadCan be high on small serversLighter
Database useLogs can grow largeLogs can grow, with controls
Settings that helpSchedule scans for quiet hours, and limit scan scopeLimit logging, and clean old logs

If your site is slow, test with the plugin turned off. Our guide on why your WordPress website is so slow shows how to measure the effect.

Free vs Premium

ItemWordfenceSolid Security
Free versionFirewall, scanner, and login security with delays on some updatesCore hardening, login protection, and checks
Paid versionReal-time rules and signatures, country blocking, premium supportExtra login tools, user security tools, and support
PricingYearly license, check current priceYearly license, check current price
Good forSites that face real threatsSites that want simple, guided protection

For most small sites, the free version of either plugin is a good start. Consider paid plans when the site earns money, holds customer data, or has been attacked before.

Common Mistakes With Security Plugins

  • Running two security plugins at once. They block each other and cause lockouts.
  • Locking yourself out with a rule that is too strict. Save a backup login method, and write down your recovery steps.
  • Ignoring alerts. Set them up to go to an address that you read.
  • Turning on every setting at once, which can break forms, payment tools, or the editor.
  • Trusting the plugin and skipping updates.
  • Skipping backups.
  • Deleting files that the scanner flags without checking them.

How to Set Up Either Plugin Safely

  1. Take a full backup, and store it away from your server.
  2. Remove other security plugins, or turn them off.
  3. Install the plugin, and run its setup guide.
  4. Turn on two-factor login for all administrators, and keep your recovery codes in a safe place.
  5. Set alerts to an address that you check.
  6. Run the first scan, and read the results with care.
  7. Turn on the firewall in learning or default mode, and test your site for a few days.
  8. Test your forms, your shop checkout, and your login after each change.
  9. Schedule scans for quiet hours.
  10. Review the logs once a week for the first month.

If a security setting breaks your site, or locks you out, our guide on how to find which plugin is breaking your site shows how to turn a plugin off from outside the dashboard.

Which Should You Choose?

Your situationBetter choiceWhy
Small blog with a few usersSolid SecuritySimple, guided, and light
Business site that handles leadsEitherAdd two-factor login and backups
Shop with customer dataWordfence, or Solid Security Pro, plus a network firewallStronger protection is worth the cost
Site that has been hacked beforeWordfenceDeeper scanning and cleanup tools
Small shared hosting planSolid SecurityLighter on resources
You want hardening helpSolid SecurityGuided checklist
You want live traffic and blocked-attack dataWordfenceDetailed live view
You manage many sitesEither, with a management toolCheck the multi-site options

A Wider Security Plan

A plugin is one layer. A good plan has several.

  • Keep WordPress, themes, and plugins updated.
  • Delete plugins and themes that you do not use.
  • Use strong, unique passwords, and a password manager.
  • Turn on two-factor login.
  • Use HTTPS on the whole site.
  • Keep daily backups, and test a restore.
  • Give each user only the access that they need.
  • Use a network-level firewall or a service from your host, if available.
  • Watch for alerts and act on them.

What to Do If Your Site Is Hacked

If a scan or a visitor tells you that your site has been hacked, follow a calm plan.

  1. Do not panic, and do not delete files at random.
  2. Take a copy of the site as it is now, for later review.
  3. Put the site in maintenance mode, or ask your host to suspend it, if visitors are at risk.
  4. Change all passwords: WordPress users, hosting, database, FTP, and email.
  5. Scan the site, and note the files and users that the scanner flags.
  6. Remove unknown admin users.
  7. Replace core files with fresh copies, and reinstall plugins and themes from official sources.
  8. If you have a clean backup from before the attack, restore it, and then update everything.
  9. Check your database for strange content, such as hidden links in posts.
  10. Find how the attacker got in, such as an old plugin or a weak password, and close that gap.
  11. Run a new scan, and watch the logs for several weeks.

A security plugin helps with steps 5 to 7 and 11. It does not replace a clean backup. If you do not feel able to do the cleanup yourself, ask a person who works with WordPress security.

Signs That Your Site May Be Under Attack

Watch for these warning signs.

  • Unknown administrator users in your user list.
  • Posts or pages that you did not write, especially with links to other sites.
  • Visitors redirected to other sites, often only on phones or from search results.
  • Warnings in the browser or in search results that your site is unsafe.
  • A sudden rise in traffic from places that you do not serve.
  • A flood of failed login attempts in your logs.
  • Files that changed without any update.
  • Emails from your host about unusual activity or resource use.
  • A slow site with no clear cause. Our guide on why your WordPress website is so slow helps you tell a hack from a normal slowdown.

If you see more than one of these, act at once.

Setting Up Two-Factor Login Properly

Two-factor login is the most useful setting in either plugin, and it is also the one that can lock you out if you set it up carelessly.

  1. Choose an authenticator app on your phone.
  2. Turn on two-factor login in the plugin for your own account first.
  3. Scan the code, and enter the first code to confirm.
  4. Save the recovery codes in a safe place, such as a password manager.
  5. Test by logging out and logging in again.
  6. Then turn it on for other administrators and editors.
  7. Keep a second way to recover, such as access to your host’s file manager.

If you lose your phone and your recovery codes, you can still get in by renaming the plugin folder over FTP. After that, set up two-factor login again on a new device.

Firewall Modes and Learning

A firewall that blocks too much will block real visitors, forms, and payment tools. Most firewalls start in a mode that learns your site.

  • Start in learning mode for a few days, if the plugin has one.
  • Visit your site as a normal user: log in, post, upload media, and use the shop.
  • Check the firewall’s log for blocked requests that look legitimate.
  • Allow those requests, if the plugin lets you.
  • Then switch to the full protection mode.

After a major change, such as a new plugin or a new theme, check the log again. A new feature may trigger rules that were not hit before.

Alerts That Help, and Alerts That Annoy

Too many alerts teach you to ignore them. Choose a short list.

AlertUseful?Notes
A new admin user was createdVeryCould be a sign of a hack
Core, plugin, or theme file changedYesCheck after each update
Scan found a threatYesRead the details before you act
Many failed loginsSometimesSend a daily summary instead of each event
A plugin has a known vulnerabilityYesUpdate or replace the plugin
Every blocked requestNoToo noisy

Send alerts to an address that you read, and test that the email arrives. If your site’s email is not reliable, see our guide on how to fix WordPress emails that are not sending, because an alert that never arrives gives you no protection.

Advertisement

Plugin Conflicts With Security Plugins

Security plugins touch many parts of WordPress, so they can clash with other tools.

  • Caching plugins may store pages that the firewall should check.
  • Page builders and form plugins may send requests that look suspicious to a strict firewall.
  • Payment plugins may call back to your site from outside addresses.
  • Another security plugin may block the same requests, or change the same files.

If a feature fails after you turn on a security setting, turn the setting off and test. Many security plugins have a mode that logs but does not block, which helps you find the problem without risk.

Host-Level Security

Some hosts provide their own firewall, malware scan, and backup. This is useful, and it works at a level below WordPress. A good setup often uses both: the host’s network protection, and a plugin for WordPress-specific checks.

Ask your host these questions:

  • Do you provide a web application firewall?
  • Do you scan for malware, and will you tell me what you find?
  • Are backups included, and how long do you keep them?
  • Can you isolate my account from others on the server?
  • What is your process if my site is hacked?

If your host already blocks most attacks at the network level, you may need fewer plugin features, and a lighter plugin may fit better.

A Monthly Security Routine

Spend thirty minutes each month on this list.

  1. Update WordPress, plugins, and themes. Test after each update.
  2. Delete unused plugins, themes, and users.
  3. Check your user list for unknown accounts.
  4. Review the scan results and the firewall log.
  5. Check that backups are running, and that you can reach them.
  6. Check that your SSL certificate and domain are in date.
  7. Check that alerts still arrive.
  8. Note any change in a short log.

A small, regular routine does more for your site than a large one-time setup.

Security Plugin Settings for Different Site Types

A simple blog

Turn on two-factor login for your account, limit login attempts, turn off the file editor, and schedule one scan a week. Keep alerts to the few that matter.

A business site with a contact form

Do the same, and test the form after you turn on the firewall. Add alerts for new admin users and changed files. Keep a backup before each update.

A shop

Use two-factor login for every user who can reach orders. Test the cart and checkout after each security change. Watch for payment callbacks that the firewall might block, and consider a paid plan and a network-level firewall.

A site with many authors

Give each person the lowest role that they need. Turn on password rules, and review the user list each month. Remove accounts of people who have left.

A membership site

Protect the login with limits and a second step, and be careful with rules that might block members who travel or use shared networks.

In every case, the plugin works best when it is paired with updates, backups, and a simple routine.

Our Verdict

Pick Wordfence when you want the deepest protection that a free plugin can offer: a firewall inside WordPress, a thorough scanner, and a live view of attacks. Accept that it asks more of your server, and plan your scan schedule.

Pick Solid Security when you want a calmer, guided tool that closes common weak points and protects your login without much fuss. It suits small sites and smaller hosting plans.

If your site earns money or holds customer data, treat either free plugin as a starting point. Add backups, a network-level firewall, two-factor login for all staff, and a paid plan if the risk justifies it.

Keeping Your Security Plugin Up to Date

A security plugin is only as good as its latest version and rules. Keep the plugin updated, and check that its signatures or rule sets are current. If your plan delays rule updates, accept that you have a short window with less protection, and cover it with other layers such as updates, strong passwords, and a network firewall.

After each plugin update, check that the firewall is still on, that scans still run on schedule, and that alerts still arrive.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is Wordfence better than Solid Security?

Wordfence has the stronger firewall and scanner. Solid Security is simpler and more focused on hardening and login protection. The better choice depends on your site and your server.

Can I use Wordfence and Solid Security together?

No. Two security plugins can conflict and lock you out. Use one.

Is the free version enough?

For many small sites, yes. Paid plans make sense for shops, sites with customer data, and sites that have been hacked before.

Will a security plugin slow down my site?

A little. Scans use server resources, so schedule them for quiet hours. Test your speed before and after.

What is two-factor authentication?

It asks for a second proof, such as a code from an app, after your password. It stops most stolen-password attacks.

Can a security plugin remove malware?

Some can help clean files, but a hacked site often needs careful manual cleanup and a restored backup. Ask a professional if you are not sure.

What if I lock myself out?

Rename the plugin’s folder over FTP, or use your host’s file manager, to turn it off. Then log in and fix the setting.

Do I still need backups?

Yes. A security plugin does not replace backups. Keep a recent copy away from your server.

Does the plugin protect against all attacks?

No. It reduces risk. Updates, strong passwords, and good habits matter just as much.

Can someone set up security for me?

Yes. If you want an experienced person to set up your security plugin and check your site, you can get WordPress management help through this Fiverr gig.

Final Thoughts

Wordfence and Solid Security are both good security plugins, and they suit different people. Wordfence is the stronger choice if you want a deep firewall, a detailed scanner, and live data. Solid Security is the easier choice if you want guided hardening, simple login protection, and a lighter feel.

Pick one, set it up with a backup and two-factor login, and test your site after each change. Then keep everything updated. Security is a habit, and a plugin is a tool that supports it.

Advertisement
Mindful reading

Better ideas, delivered thoughtfully.

Receive useful articles, thoughtful perspectives and practical knowledge from Mindful Tomorrow without unnecessary noise.

Scroll to Top